Shale Gas Development and Drinking Water Quality
This paper estimates drinking water quality effects of SGD in Pennsylvania, and fnds localized impacts for well pads drilled within 1 km of drinking water source intakes. A recent study fnds that Pennsylvanians in counties with shale gas development spent $19 million on bottled water in 2010 due to perceived risks to drinking water (Wrenn, Klaiber, and Jaenicke 2016). Our results suggest that these perceived risks may in fact be justifed. In assessing the costs of these impacts, however, one must simultaneously consider the share of the population that is exposed to these drinking water externalities: although 83 percent of the population in Pennsylvania sources drinking water from community water systems, only 14 percent are served by groundwater CWSs. While there are potentially large costs related to drinking water violations in terms of health (Currie et al. 2013) and avoidance behavior (Graff Zivin, Neidell, and Schlenker 2011; Wrenn, Klaiber, and Jaenicke 2016), the associated external costs of these well pad developments in Pennsylvania are likely to be small due to the size of the affected population. An important caveat is that exposure to SGD activity largely depends on the location of shale plays and is thus heterogeneous across regions. The advent of horizontal drilling has allowed SGD operations to proceed in densely populated urban areas, where drinking water source locations may be close by. As such, our estimates would imply large external costs from compromises to drinking water quality if applied to other regions of SGD activity. These results not only inform policymakers who set and enforce health-protective standards for the industry, but researchers who study the mechanisms of pollutant exposure to better understand how these operations affect health in their communities.